Cat and Bear's Blog

Australian Trans Prison Policy

Went down a bit of a rabbit hole and looked into prison policies regarding transgender inmates here in Australia. This is from 2000 so quite outdated:

policy-table
I was surprised by the relative progressiveness of the NSW system regarding self-identification. NSW also explicitly requires the continuation of hormone therapy and sexual reassignment surgeries, while this is more implicit in most other jurisdictions with rights to healthcare. QLD is unsurprisingly particularly regressive. I know that the ACT has since adopted a full self-identification requirement with no medical intervention required.

It also shows that across Australian trans prisoners of both MtF and FtM can end up in both/either male or female prisons.

An important thing to note is that the above is either 1) out of date, 2) not always put in practice, 3) possibly wrong in cases, as well as 4) the inconsistency between prison policy and birth certificate legislation can lead to inconsistencies. For example, there was fairly widespread reporting about the horrors endured by a trans woman in WA Mens' Prisons despite the above noting the WA Prison policy would identify her as a woman.

Anyway, the reason I looked into this was to see if trans men are ever put into men's prisons (after seeing the claim that they are not). Well, they can be and it unsurprisingly isn't pleasant either:

a transgender male prisoner held in a Queensland men’s prison (the prisoner had undergone some sexual reassignment surgery but still had a vagina) pleaded with authorities, unsuccessfully, to transfer him to a female prison for his own safety. The prisoner reported being threatened with sexual assault by other prisoners, and ended up attempting suicide as a result of his predicament.

This variety is all within Australia. I think its quite important to acknowledge the incredible breadth and diversity of potential experience based on jurisdiction. A story from NSW can't necessarily be generalised to QLD.

#feminism #gender