Breadwinner backlash: The gendered effects of industrial decline
The link (root?) of Trumpism and misogyny is pretty well discussed to death. It's kinda obvious that the reason coal mining is important to MAGA isn't because it's a major employer (down to 38,000), important for the economy, or important for national security. But because it's a masculine ideal of dirty, grimey, hard manly work that also happens to be concentrated in a swing state.
Still, it's neat that someone is trying to empirically validate this and build a more cohesive theory around it.
We study how layoffs of low-skilled men and concurrent shifts in workforce composition toward women affect voting. We theorize that this labor market rebalancing produces “nostalgic” coalitions of men and women that seek a return to male-breadwinner family models. Such attitudes fuel right-wing movements that pledge to protect conservative gender roles. Evidence from local labor markets and voting in the United States over the last two decades, as well as a longitudinal study tracking individual Americans over several decades, support this theory.
Some important points in the conclusion:
This paper helps make sense of the support right-wing parties find among women and men, speaking to scholarly debates over the anti-globalization backlash that has afflicted advanced economies in recent years. Rather than this backlash having a purely economic origin, we find that it is intimately interwoven with cultural factors...
This paper suggests that layoffs of men in isolation do not tilt communities toward the right. Rather, it is the coincidence of layoffs with a rebalancing of economic power from men to women that lays the foundation for right-wing gains...
Our findings delineate conditions under which growth in women's paid labor may not produce a move to the left, offering an economic account of why large numbers of women continue to support right-wing candidates such as Trump