Cat and Bear's Blog

On Dworkin's Letter's From a War Zone

I've been reading some speeches/writings from Andrea Dworkin's Letters From a War Zone and it's immediately clear why she's quite the divisive character.

The passion she writes with really comes to the fore, it's particularly evocative and moving. I've written elsewhere that the art form of the Manifesto is somewhat lost, and that so much of modern political text is either wonkish academia or pop mass marketable (or sometimes a mix of the two!). So it's nice to have some real fire. I particularly liked this opener from Biological Superiority: The World's Most Dangerous and Deadly Idea (the speech that got me onto Dworkin this time round in the first place):

Hisses. Women shouting at me: slut, bisexual, she fucks men. And before I had spoken, I had been trembling, more afraid to speak than I had ever been. And, in a room of 200 sister lesbians, as angry as I have ever been. "Are you a bisexual?" some woman screamed over the pandemonium, the hisses and shouts merging into a raging noise. "I'm a Jew," I answered

The flipside of this, and I know this might come across as a little dismissive, is that she can come across a little too deep in the trenches and this doesn't really help her win over friends.

Sometimes I cannot believe the world I live in. Usually I go along, believing. As a feminist and a writer, I study rape, pornography, wife-beating. I see the abused bodies of women, in life and in newspapers. I meet, in life and in books, the torn minds, the locked-in victims. I grieve, I rage, but through it all, I believe.

You really believe this. You can feel how these stories have impacted her and shaped her, and it adds real venom to her words. For example, here in Pornography: The New Terrorism:

Pornography is the propaganda of sexual fascism. Pornography is the propaganda of sexual terrorism. Images of women bound, bruised, and maimed on virtually every street corner, on every magazine rack, in every drug store, in movie house after movie house, on billboards, on posters pasted on walls, are death threats to a female population in rebellion. Female rebellion against male sexual despotism, female rebellion against male sexual authority, is now a reality throughout this country. The men, meeting rebellion with an escalation of terror, hang pictures of maimed female bodies in every public place.

This is very evocative, but I'm not sure it is particularly convincing for those not already galvanized in similar fashion. There's no room in her words for compromise; to imagine a world with a healthy, productive, feminist pornography. And because I come from a much more sex-positive background of feminism this feels like it is talking past me to an extent, because to me such a world is the goal.

Her I Want a Twenty-Four-Hour Truce During Which There Is No Rape is particularly relevant to me on this, being her speech to an "audience primarily of political men who say that they are antisexist." Her venom and anger is clear, and it means the speech is chastising and critical:

Hiding behind guilt, that's my favorite. I love that one. Oh, it's horrible, yes, and I'm so sorry... And I'm sorry that you feel so bad—so uselessly and stupidly bad—because there is a way in which this really is your tragedy. And I don't mean because you can't cry. And I don't mean because there is no real intimacy in your lives. And I don't mean because the armor that you have to live with as men is stultifying: and I don't doubt that it is. But I don't mean any of that.

Now you might say, "But yes! She is right!" Being right is kinda beside the point. My point is that pathos in a speech is about connecting with your audience, and confrontation can be a risky way to try and achieve this. Its a really powerful speech, but the proof is right here in the pudding that instead of writing an angry email to Larry Flynt I've instead written about feeling kinda grated and demoralised by it on Tumblr. So was the speech actually effective at its nominal purpose?

Any vegan, environmentalist and I imagine feminist would be aware of the moral minority or 'do-gooder derogation' effect. It doesn't really matter if you are right or wrong, being outwardly provocative in your moral righteousness can backfire. I think Dworkin has the interesting mix of being [mostly] right, a very talented writer, and very much a victim of this effect.

At some point I'll give one of her more theory-heavy books a whirl and see what its like.

#feminism