Cat and Bear's Blog

The Dialectic of Sex and Culture

The Dialectic of Sex, Chapter 8 (Male) Culture has some thoughts that are pretty interesting to recontextualise into modern discussions around generative AI I think.

Key passage:

For the higher percentages of women in art lately may tell us more about the state of art than about the state of women. Are we to feel cheered that women have taken over in a capacity soon to be automated out? ... That art is no longer a vital centre that attracts the best men of our generation may also be a product of the male/female division... But the animation of women and homosexuals in the arts today may signify only the scurrying of rats near a dying body.

It's a good fifty years later, but we are now at the cusp of seeing a mass collapse in the art industry due to generative AI, which is going to disproportionately impact women.

graph

But what's maybe more interesting in relation to The Dialectic of Sex is not so much the economic impact, but the cultural impact of 'art' or 'culture' broadly becoming increasingly automated by algorithms. Particularly the fact that these algorithms are largely produced and owned by men. I'm not sure how the training data breaks down in terms of originating gender, but the possible sexist outcomes are fairly well discussed.

Firestone continues:

But it has not yet created women artists, women's new literacy has certainly created a female audience. Just as male audiences have always demanded, and received, male art to reinforce their particular view of reality, so a female audience demands a "female" art to reinforce the female reality. Thus the birth of the crude feminine novel in the nineteenth century, leading to the love story of our own day, so ever-present in popular culture ("soap opera"); the women's magazine trade; Valley of the Dolls. These may be crude beginnings. Most of this art is as yet primitive, clumsy, poor. But occasionally the female reality is documented as clearly as the male reality has always been, as, for example, in the work of Anne Sexton.

An interesting trend over the past few decades is the actual newfound dominance of women in terms of literacy and literature consumption. Female authored book sales are now greater than male-authored book sales, and women make up 80% of fiction sales. So much so, that there are now obituaries for the 'dad book'. We've also seen the growth and newfound dominance of female authors at a critical acclaim level - see all the controversy around the Hugo awards over the past decade.

In terms of the "primitive, clumsy, poor" art, its hard not to see the latest iteration of this phenomenon in the current romantasy trend (or the Twilight/Fifty Shades of Grey clitlit fad a little earlier). No derision intended here; everyone deserves some pulp fiction.

But when it comes to Firesmith's concluding paragraph of this section:

Eventually, out of this ferment - perhaps very soon - we may see the emergence of an authentic female art. But the development of "female" art is not to be viewed as reactionary, like its counterpart, the male School of Virility. Rather it is progressive: an exploration of the strictly female reality is a necessary step to correct the warp in a sexually biased culture. It is only after we have integrated the dark side of the moon into our world view that we can begin to talk seriously of universal culture.

I have to wonder if the progress in women's voices, representation, and 'culture' is going to get the rug-pulled out from under them due to generative AI. Issues of AI rocking the literary world are plenty, and organisations from creative writing contests to actual court systems are being flooded by AI generated content. When self-published books are becoming inundated with AI content (as is Spotify with AI songs), I have to wonder how many of the popcorn, pulpy reads like today's romantasy titles will remain authentically written by women in the future.

Will this past decade be the peak of 'authentic female art' prior to humanity's culture being subsumed by a male-oriented algorithmic borg? Just kinda depressing thoughts, and that's coming from someone relatively AI-optimistic....

#The Dialectic of Sex #ai #feminism #nf