The Dialectic of Sex and Urbanism
Finally managed to finish The Dialectic of Sex. Firestone leaves the best right to the end: the discussion of urban planning!
This discussion comes in two parts, first with housing then broader city planning. Her vision of housing is linked to her vision of the household: namely larger, non-nuclear family households of 12-15 people of a variety of ages, relations etc and loosely bound to each through a ~10 year legal contract. The purpose of such households is to share household duties across a group, be a unit that could raise children (not necessarily with a biological connection), and I would extrapolate to things like medical decisions rights, a degree of shared legal access etc (similar to how married couples can make some decisions for each other today).
To support such households, she suggests mass produced, pre-fabricated and modular house construction that could essentially be easily modified for different household needs. This would be cool shit.
A quick anecdote to emphasise how much the nuclear family model is baked into actual policy. My city had a "housing demonstration project": basically a handful of plots had the typical "detached suburban home" zoning restrictions removed from them to allow experimentation with another form of housing.
One plot got taken up three semi/near-retired couples, who all knew each other, and wanted a sort of dream "let's retire together" arrangement. These weren't hippies or idealists, but wealthy professionals. So they wanted mostly-self contained units for each couple, but then a large shared common area, and things like a shared laundry, shared garage, shared garden, communal kitchen etc.
And even as part of an intentionally experimental project, they still got micromanaged to hell and back. For example, they weren't allowed just a shared laundry, each unit would need one. The most infuriating thing was they weren't allowed a shower in the guest bedroom's bathroom, because it "created too much livable space." There were obviously concerns they were effectively creating a fourth unit with the guest suite, but so fucking what!?? Why are we legislating a limit on showers!?
The designs, re-designs and dozens of hoops that needed to be jumped through before construction could even began delayed the housing project by years. And it makes me so sad, because I think it would be a truly tremendously beneficial model of housing to proliferate. It would avoid the "false home" experience of the overcrowded Russian communal apartment, while also the atomised isolation of today's suburbia. It'd be great for uni students or young professionals looking for temporary roommates, for new families looking to have support nearby, for established familes looking to provide greater autonomy for teenagers, for people looking to care for their elderly relatives (the granny flat), etc etc.
The second part of Firestone's discussion regards the greater urban planning, where she envisions the ideal urban framework to be much like a university campus.
Hell's yes. What defines a university campus? Walkability. Mixed use of residential (colleges), commercial (like food and book stores), offices (for academics and admin), cultural institutions (libraries, art spaces), recreation (sports, student social spots etc).
It's almost disappointing that Firestone doesn't go more into zoning and city planning, given how much it has shaped the modern culture and life. The stereotypical isolated, 1950s housewife is largely a product of the newly formed suburbs, where the patriarch drove to the business district and if the wife got out at all, it was to a strip mall or supermarket surrounded by carpark.
One has to wonder, of you could take a snapshot of a city in 1960 and put a dot for every woman and every man at 11am in the morning, how clearly gender segregated would it be? I imagine the CBD would be a sea of men with the occasional secretary or assistant. Meanwhile suburbia would be peppered with women, isolated and atomised.
(I might be exaggerating this a little, but I think if you perhaps filtered to white women/men of the ages 25-50 the effect would be profound. Though seeing the racial and gendered segregation would also fascinate me).
So my not-at-all slanted or biased reading of The Dialectic of Sex is thus: the feminist struggle is intricately tied to the struggle for zoning reform and land value taxation!
Free Trade! Free Land! Free Women!