The Dialectic of Sex by Shulamith Firestone
I've been reading The Dialectic of Sex (1970) by Shulamith Firestone, a book previously mostly known to me as the "use artificial wombs to overcome sex difference" book.
It, of course, covers much more, and I've just finished the chapter on Freudianism. I've long considered Freud as the second most damaging thinking to the broader Left (I won't digress on the first), and so it was really quite satisfying to see him so thoroughly eviscerated here. But the value from Firestone (I'll begrudgingly admit) is what she salvages from Freud. There's a parallel here I'm sure she'd enjoy with Marx and Hegel, and she essentially sets out to set Freud "right side up."
Essentially, she positions feminism and Freudianism as parallel thought. They both stem from reaction to "one of the smuggest periods of Western civilisation", the Victorian era, replete with its extreme sexual repression, oppression and caricatured "familycentredness."
What she credits Freud with is the "rediscovery of sexuality" and placing sexuality "as the prime life force." Freud's problem then is less so his subject matter, or not even so much his approach, but the fact that he is so (so, so, so incredibly) clouded by his misogyny. Firestone attempts to excise the misogyny from Freudian analysis, and replace it with a more clear-eyed view of power relations within the prototypical family unit of the time - the patriarchal nuclear family.
This analysis is focused on a basic triad of Father, Mother and Son. Ideas of fucking one's mother and castration are dropped, and instead the basic dynamic of 'Father and Mother Power over Child' and 'Father Power over Mother and Child' are examined. Under this dynamic, it is little wonder that a young boy seeks comfort from his shared oppressor in the form of a disciplinarian father, and that a boy coming-of-age sees that father as his ticket to power of his own.
What is also relevant in reading The Dialectic of Sex, however, is also what seems increasingly irrelevant. Firestone concedes that "more recent versions of the nuclear family... may blur this essential relationship beyond recognition." But that itself was written more than half-a-century ago now! 1970 was the year the first US state adopted no-fault divorce (signed by divorcee-Ronnie Reagan in California). Australia would hit this milestone in 1975. Sex discrimination in employment legislation would hit major milestones in the Equal Opportunity Employment Act of 1972 (with a similar Sex Discrimination Act of 1984 in Australia). In the US, the oral contraceptive pill only became widely available to younger women from 1971 with ratification of the 26th amendment.
I'm not trying to downplay current feminist struggles continuing in these areas (though it is worth celebrating past victories). But you can see remarkable trends taking off following the 1960s regarding family dynamics and women's economic position. This, if anything, helps validate Firestone's focus on things such as reproductive rights.
The Pill increased women's university attendance and graduation; it increased participation in professions and delayed age of marriage; and it significantly helped to close the gender wage gap. Just after Firestone published her book, the amount of women in higher professions like medicine and law shot up to almost parity with men:
And women are now attaining higher education more than men:
Family culture is also significantly changing. Fathers spend around ~3x more time with their children than in the 1960s, closing the gap with women from a 1:4 ratio to around 1:2.
Side note: I really wonder what is going on in France lmao:
So profound the changes, less than half of families are the """traditional""" structure nowadays.
Anyway, you get the gist: there have been remarkable advancements since 1970. This can be credited to an combination of technological progress and feminist activism.
This progress is also not uniform, not just across the globe but within countries. But I think its worth considering both the potentialities and the new emerging problems from these changing dynamics. Firestone credits this basic family formation as impacting "whole historical developments" and at the "very foundations of Western culture and civilisation." I expect we'll continue to see very significant ramifications from these changes into the future.
Just as a final little note: I've mostly glossed over Firestone's discussion of homosexuality (feeling particularly dated) and the incest taboo (particularly Freudian). I'll probably try to reflect on this more once I finish the whole book.