The Dialectic of Sex and the Cybernation
Finished the last chapter of The Dialectic of Sex (only conclusion to go), which is on 'Feminism and Ecology'. A good chapter, and even more relevant to my musings on the chapter on culture. It deals directly with 'cybernation'. Quote spam upcoming:
Another scientific development that we find difficult to absorb into our traditional value system is the dawn of cybernation, the takeover of work functions by increasingly complex machines - machines that may soon equal or surpass man in original thinking and problem-solving...
Cybernation, like birth control, can be a double-edged sword. Like artificial reproduction, to envision it in the hands of the present powers is to envision a nightmare. We need not elaborate...
But again... the distinction between misuse of science and the value of science itself is not often kept clear. In this case, though perhaps the response may not be quite so hysterical and evasive, we still often have the same unimaginative concentration on the evils of the machine itself, rather than a recognition of its revolutionary significance.... the underlying problem is one for which there is no precedent: qualitative change in humanity's basic relationships to both its production and its reproduction. We will need almost overnight... a new culture based on a radical redefinition of human relationships and leisure for the masses. To so radically redefine our relationship to production and reproduction requires the destruction at once of the class system as well as the family. We will be beyond arguments about who is "bringing home the bacon" - no one will be bringing it home, because no one will be "working." ...Machines thus could acts as the perfect equalizer, obliterating the class system based on exploitation of labour.
Now, these sorts of predictions are nothing particularly new. The Communist Manifesto notes:
The less the skill and exertion of strength implied in manual labour, in other words, the more modern industry becomes developed, the more is the labour of men superseded by that of women. Differences of age and sex have no longer any distinctive social validity for the working class.
The Right to Be Lazy has similarly utopian predictions, as did Keynes in the early 20th century. But I think it is clear that modern AI is now qualitatively different to the computing machines of the past. It has passed an advanced number crunching machine and is now digesting and spitting out basically the collective sum of human written knowledge.
Shulasmith's predictions also seem fairly spot on, if half a century early:
- Automation will at first provide new jobs for women, but then these will be the first to be automated away.
- The status of the 'head of the household' due to changing economics and housework.
- Massive unrest of the young, poor and unemployed.
I'll spare my rant on intellectual property here, but suffice to say, I think the deliberately created monopolies we have created through policy to allow for the concentration of wealth in the form of things like scientific advancement of LLMs and related technologies is going to have very profound and dire impacts.
I'm not really sure how to effectively shoehorn in this last quote, but it always springs to my mind when discussing automation and I think its worth pondering here to. From Marx's Grundrisse (forgive the universal male pronouns lol):
Labour no longer appears so much to be included within the production process; rather, the human being comes to relate more as watchman and regulator to the production process itself... He steps to the side of the production process instead of being its chief actor. In this transformation, it is neither the direct human labour he himself performs, nor the time during which he works, but rather the appropriation of his own general productive power, his understanding of nature and his mastery over it by virtue of his presence as a social body – it is, in a word, the development of the social individual which appears as the great foundation-stone of production and of wealth... With that, production based on exchange value breaks down, and the direct, material production process is stripped of the form of penury and antithesis.
This seems enormously relevant to where things are heading with AI.