Cat and Bear's Blog

The Dialectic of Sex: Love and Romance

The Dialectic of Sex update, having finished the chapters on Love and Romance.

The chapter on love sorta swings between:

The chapter on love is also quite cynical about the sexual revolution, seeing its main consequence as increasing the expectations on women to 'put out'. As I mentioned in my previous post, Firestone was writing just as women's rights began to massively accelerate and transform society (the pill was only legal since 1960, and still only for married women). So with the benefit of hindsight, it feels a little off the mark.

A very important sidebar:

Firestone writes that, from the perspective of men, "to be a "groovy chick" is the ideal." The SCUM Manifesto (1967) also makes regular use of the term "groovy", e.g:

I just get tickled that "groovy" is actually how they spoke in the 1960s. It seems like such a caricature but it was legit just the language lol. One has to wonder if to-be-classic feminist texts penned today will speak of "rizz" and "swag" or other such slang.

Now onto The Culture of Romance

I much preferred this chapter. It opens with an important thesis:

Romanticism develops in proportion to the liberation of women from their biology.

Firestone laments "erotomania", with an "epidemic level" of "sexual excitement" accessible from "every magazine cover, film screen, TV tube, subway sign". I have to wonder what fresh hell she would perceive the modern era of TikTok, OnlyFans and 4k pornography instantly streamable through your smart fridge.

I do wonder though, should this be seen as an amplification of "romanticism" to all new, caricaturised heights, or have we just seen a near death of romanticism entirely. In the modern era of easy-swiping dating culture, a decreasing amount of dating occurring, a so-called "sex recession" or "loneliness epidemic", and the growth of movements like 'MGTOW' and whatever is going on in South Korea, have we had a turn to something qualitatively different?

As a final note to wrap this up, I did quite like her ending statement which I'll quote at length:

Sex objects are beautiful. An attack on them can be confused with an attack on beauty itself. Feminists need not get so pious in their efforts that they feel they must flatly deny the beauty of the face on the cover of Vogue. For this is not the point. The real question is: is the face beautiful in a human way - does it allow for growth and flux and decay, does it express negative as well as positive emotions, does it fall apart without artificial props - or does it falsely imitate the very different beauty of an inanimate object, like wood trying to be metal?

To attack eroticism creates similar problems. Eroticism is exciting. No one wants to get rid of it. Life would be a drab and routine affair without at least that spark. That's just the point. Why has all joy and excitement been concentrated, driven into one narrow, difficult-to-find alley of human experience, and all the rest laid waste? When we demand the elimination of eroticism, we mean not the elimination of sexual joy and excitement but it rediffusion over - there's plenty to around, it increases with use - the spectrum of our lives.

Impossible for me to directly link that to the lyrics "Whaddaya know… sex has been distorted and vilified. I’m scared of my attraction to body types. If everything desired is objectified then maybe eroticism needs to be redefined."

Note: I've skimmed over the chapter on race. I don't want to wade into American racial politics too much as a non-American. And with the Freudian psychoanalysis it's just a minefield to step through lol. Like yes this is metaphor and yes she is critiquing this situation, but like, I don't wanna go into: "the black man is a pawn in the game of the white man's sexuality. For as we have seen, the black man is not a complete man, nor yet a homosexual... but a degraded male."

#The Dialectic of Sex #feminism #nf